Menu
The common law provides protection against many forms of unfair methods of competing, such as false advertising, misrepresentations regarding a competitor’s products, misuse of unregistered trademarks, misappropriation of the trade dress of products, misappropriation of trade secrets, being among a few. Quite often, unfair competition claims are included in litigation relating to other claims, such as traditional trademark infringement.
The federal trademark law includes a section that deals with false advertising and what would be considered an unregistered trademark infringement. Many of the same rules regarding the establishing and protecting of trademarks are applicable to unregistered trademarks that are the subject of this type of action. With an unregistered trademark, the burden is on the company claiming trademark rights to prove that it does have an enforceable trademark.
A violation of trade secrets occurs when another obtains or exploits the secret information using unfair methods. Breaking into a competitor’s plant or bribing employees would be obvious violations. Likewise, breaching a confidentiality agreement or inducing a former employee to breach a confidentiality agreement could be violations. Reverse engineering a product that was purchased commercially is not a trade secret violation.
Trade secret violations are enforced by way of a civil action in the state courts. Claims of trade secret violation may also be made in federal courts when coupled with other claims.
Trade secrets are protected under the common law and, in some states, by state statute. Obtaining protection in the courts for misappropriation of trade secrets requires a company to itself undertake steps to protect the secrecy status of that information. Company sign-in rules, restricted building areas and signs, visitor name badges, visitor sign-in sheets, and confidentiality agreements are some of the efforts a company can undertake to establish secrecy status for its valuable information.
A trade secret can potentially last indefinitely provided its secrecy is maintained.
A trade secret can be any information of value to a company that is maintained in confidence, and can include any formula, process, pattern, device, or compilation of information used in a business. Trade secret information may encompass confidential financial information, technical information, business plans and information, marketing strategies, and research.
A trade secret is secret information used in a company’s business that gives the company an opportunity to obtain an advantage over competitors who do not use the information. Protection of trade secrets is a result of the law’s recognition that competitors should not be permitted to use fundamentally improper methods to obtain confidential information of a business.
The traditional test as to whether a later trademark infringes the rights in an earlier trademark is the question of whether a likelihood of confusion will result from the use of the later mark. That issue of a likelihood of confusion takes a number of factors into account.
Important among those factors are the particular trademarks in question and the products or services on which the marks are used, but, depending on the circumstances, other factors come into play such as the marketing channels in which the products are distributed and the target customer base. The issue of infringement is not necessarily a simple one, and it is not limited to a comparison of identical marks on identical products or services.
A more recently recognized form of trademark violation is that of dilution. If a trademark is classified as a “famous” mark, then it can be used to prevent others from using similar marks on noncompetitive products or services that “dilute” the trademark significance of
the mark. This is a developing area of the trademark law. While in many cases, particularly when consumer goods are involved, everyone would generally agree whether a trademark is famous or not, this may not always be the case.
Both with a traditional trademark infringement action or one involving dilution, enforcement is by way of a civil action brought in either federal or state court. It is also possible to bring an action before the International Trade Commission to stop infringing imports.
A company is obligated to avoid creating a likelihood of confusion with the products and trademarks of others. While a company cannot knowingly adopt a confusingly similar trademark to another’s trademark of which they are aware, there is no legal mandate that a company undertake a trademark clearance search before adopting a name or mark. Nonetheless, a trademark clearance search prior to adoption is a good idea. This is true regardless of whether a company intends to itself pursue a registration for its new mark. The trademark registration process takes nearly a year or even more. Even if a registration is not pursued, it may take months or even years for a competitor with a registration to learn of your company’s use of a mark and, therefore, a long time before a dispute arises. In either case, significant marketing efforts and expenditures can be undertaken during this delay, all of which are potentially wasted if a company must stop using a mark.
Once a company has formulated a bona fide intent to use a trademark in interstate commerce, an application can be filed for that mark. Although an application can be filed based upon the actual use of a trademark, such use is not necessary for the initial application filing. At some point prior to the issuance of the federal registration, commercial use of the trademark must be commenced. Proof of that actual trademark use must be provided to the Trademark Office in the form of a written affidavit or declaration swearing to this use and a specimen that shows how the trademark is actually used on the product or with the service. The procedures and requirements involved in filing a trademark application are discussed in further detail on the Trademark Office website: www.uspto.gov/main/trademarks.htm. Once the application is filed, it is assigned to an Examining Attorney at the Patent and Trademark Office who is thereafter responsible for that application. It is not uncommon for it to take six months or more to receive a first substantive action from the Examining Attorney on the application. This takes the form of a written communication, called an “Office Action,” that states any reasons for objection to the registration of your mark. It is common for the Examining Attorney to initially raise some form of objection to the application. If there is an objection or some further action needed to be taken by the applicant, the applicant is allowed six months to submit a written response to the Office Action. Although it is possible to conduct either a personal or a telephone interview with the Examining Attorney, responses are typically written, and a written response would normally be required even if some type of interview takes place. The written response may take any number of approaches, such as explaining why the mark is believed to be properly registrable despite the initial objection, providing information or corrections requested by the Examining Attorney, or otherwise responding to the points raised in the Office Action.
Ultimately, an allowed application is published prior to issuance of a registration. This allows other companies to pursue an objection, referred to as an “Opposition,” if the other company feels that this registration would damage the other company.
A trademark can last indefinitely as long as it continues in use and is not abandoned. A Federal Registration may be renewed every ten years if the mark remains in use. When a trademark is first federally registered, after five years an affidavit must be filed to establish that the mark is still in use, and if that use has been continuous, the registration can become “incontestable.” At that point, the validity of the registration can only be attacked for limited bases, such as abandonment.
Trademarks are adjectives, not nouns or verbs. The trademark should, therefore, be followed by the generic or common descriptive name of the product. For example, it would be proper to refer to buying a “Bic pen” but improper to refer to buying a “Bic.” It is possible that the use of a trademark as a noun or a verb would cause the mark to eventually lose its distinctiveness and, therefore, its protectability as a trademark. This is particularly true for trademarks applied to new products. The words “escalator,” “aspirin,” “cellophane,” and “shredded wheat” where all trademarks at one time which have lost their distinctiveness. For similar reasons, a trademark should never be used in the possessive form and should not be used in the plural form.
If a trademark is not registered, it is permissible to place the designation TM or SM by the mark. This indicates that your company perceives itself as having trademark rights in that term, although the mark is not registered. When a mark is registered, and only when it is registered, the statutory notice ® should be used. There are other forms of statutory notice that include “Registered in U.S. Patent Office,” or “Reg. U.S. Pat. Off.” It is also helpful to print the trademark in lettering or format that stands out from surrounding lettering, whether by size, coloring, or font.
If you have additional questions about trademarks, contact our Michigan trademark attorneys at (616) 975-5500.
© 2026 Gardner, Linn, Burkhart & Ondersma LLP| Disclaimer | Privacy Policy